| I am convinced that a new HVAC engineering paradigm
will sweep our land soon. To say it is my current technical passion
is a real understatement. To very briefly state the pillars of this
new paradigm, they are:
I. The real intent of ASHRAE standard 62 cannot
be met with an all air VAV system (that leaves those who design this way
wide open to litigation). Therefore, a separate, dedicated OA system
must be used to supply conditioned air directly into each space of the
building (it can not be mixed in with an all air VAV system).
II. Condition the OA to a dew point low enough
(around 45F) to accommodate 100% of the space latent loads. This
can be accomplished very energy efficiently with a dual-wheel heat-recovery
system in conjunction with a chilled water coil. This de-coupling
of the latent and sensible space loads essentially eliminates microbial
problems throughout the building and paves the way for the 3rd pillar.
III. The remaining sensible space loads can be
accommodated with a parallel system that could be fan coil units, unitary
equipment, a VAV system, or radiant ceiling panels (all operating with
dry surfaces!). Energy transport, via cool water (55F), can be accomplished
by the functional integration of the un-insulated fire suppression system
(clearly approved in NFPA 13) at a marked reduction in first cost.
I happen to favor the radiant ceiling panel approach, something our European
colleagues have been very successfully using for over 15 years. Intense
activity is currently underway by my grad students and I in the development
of the optimal ceiling radiant panel for this application. The improved
IAQ, and thermal comfort that results from de-coupling the sensible and
latent loads cannot be underestimated. Further, the first costs and
energy costs of the new paradigm when using radiant cooling are significant.
Finally, savings in ceiling plenum depth, with ductwork for only about
20% of the normal all air VAV system and flat radiant panels could easily
be three feet or more per floor. This could represent a significant
reduction in the initial construction costs of such buildings.
As I see it, there are three near-term goals that
must be achieved:
1. The paradigm must be implemented into
buildings located in each of the 4 major quadrants of the USA, and that
is where you could really help me. I am optimistic that the US Department
of Energy will want to be involved with the projects by funding a portion
of the design expense and by funding the instrumentation and performance
monitoring/analysis tasks.
2. A professional development program must
be developed and deployed around the country, aimed at engineering and
contracting professionals, as well as building owners. Holding these
programs in a major transportation hub and near one of the prototype buildings
with the new paradigm in place will give the owners and design professionals
a chance to "kick the tires," so to speak. By so doing, a rapid implementation
of the new paradigm is more likely.
3. The U.S. ceiling radiant cooling panel
industry must be developed/geared up to meet the potential $5 billion/yr
to $50 billion/yr business opportunity. Otherwise, unnecessarily
expensive panels must be imported from Europe.
|