Plagiarism in Group Work
Mr. Finley assigns a research problem
in a high school calculus class. The problem is quite difficult
and will require the collaborative time and effort of a team.
Mr. Finley divides the class into groups of four students, gives
them instructions, and tells them when the problem will be due.
Pete's group has an initial meeting
and decides to divide up the work and then collaborate the information.
Valeria, one of Pete's group members, offers to write a particular
section of the paper based on some great information she found
on the Internet. The other members of the group, including Pete,
divide the remaining work and proceed with their respective
research.
One week before the project is
due, Pete finds out that Valeria has chosen to "copy and paste"
most of her paper from the Internet source. Pete picks up on
Valeria's plagiarism and knows it is wrong, but he needs an
"A" on this research problem in order to pass Calculus. Pete
confronts Valeria and asks her to redo her paper without plagiarizing,
but Valeria claims she is too busy with her other class work
and her part-time job. She assures Pete that Mr. Finley will
never discover the plagiarism, and that if he does, that she
will take complete blame for it.
Pete finds himself in an extremely
uncomfortable position. He feels partly responsible for the
plagiarism because he has discovered it; however, Valeria claims
she will take all of the blame. Should Pete talk to Mr. Finley
about the situation? Should he confer with the other group members?
Return to the Cases developed
by PSU students
Penn State
is committed to affirmative action, equal opportunity, and
the diversity of its workforce.
|